Gun Boring? No! Gun fascinating!

By

Posted on

Last month, we were able to complete one of the last major steps in the conservation of USS Monitor’s two XI-Inch Dahlgren shell guns: boring concretion out of the barrels. Material Culture Specialist Hannah recently showed off what we found in this process (coal is, indeed, cool), but why clean the gun bores to begin with? And how do you actually go about doing that, anyway?

Microscopic image of grey cast iron, sampled from a Civil War period Hotchkiss bolt. The squiggly, black lines and nodules are graphite, surrounded by lighter-colored iron.

The ‘why’ has a few pieces to it. There are benefits to our archaeological knowledge of the wreck, but our primary concern was keeping the guns in good condition. Monitor’s guns are made of iron, and specifically are made of grey cast iron. Grey cast iron is not 100% pure iron; it contains about 4% carbon, and that carbon exists as flakes of graphite locked in by the metal surrounding it – picture little shavings of pencil lead and you won’t be that far off.

When grey cast iron is immersed in salt water, it corrodes – rusts – and a couple things happen. First, as the iron corrodes it dissolves out of the surface, and combines with calcium and other materials in the water to form “concretion.”

Concretion inside of one of Monitor’s guns. Concretion is a hard, dense corrosion product which forms on iron when it corrodes in seawater.

And second, as the iron moves out of the gun, the graphite is left behind. So the guns as you see them now do still have a solid metal core, but the outer surface is mostly graphite down to about ¼ inch in depth.

Now… how does all of this play into the conservation of the guns specifically? Our primary goal for all Monitor objects is to remove ocean salts (specifically chlorides), since these make the material unstable and will destroy the object if they’re not removed. Grey cast iron is more difficult to remove salt from than other metals. The salt exists mostly at the metal surface underneath the graphite, so there is an extra ‘layer’ that salt needs to travel through to get back out. If you have concretion on top of graphite on top of salt, that’s two extra layers. The graphite is very porous, so it is possible to soak salts back out through it. The concretion… not so much; it is a much denser, harder material, and it becomes virtually impossible to get enough salt out of iron that is still covered in concretion. So the entire surface of a cast iron object – like an XI-Inch Dahlgren – must be cleaned to remove concretion, or else it won’t be possible to get all the salt out and stabilize the material. And the entire surface, in this case, includes the 11-feet-long interior of the gun bore, not just the outside. We’re all pretty talented with a chisel around here, but 11 feet is a little bit beyond our reach!

The coring drill used to clean the guns. This system is adjustable in all dimensions so that conservators are able to line up the drill with the gun barrel, removing concretion without damaging the gun.

And that brings us to how do you go about boring a Dahlgren, especially one where the outer surface has turned into fragile graphite. After a lot of research and design work, we decided to use a custom horizontal coring drill system. This let us use a series of different drill bits to clear concretion out of the gun bores, all the way to the back of the gun!

 

The first step in drilling is to make sure that the coring bit is going to travel exactly down the center of the gun. And I mean EXACTLY; otherwise you could start cutting little ledges into the bore, and nobody wants that. The easiest way to get started is actually to clean a short distance into the gun by hand. So the first thing we did for each gun was just that – we cleaned as far in with a hammer and chisel as we could get.

Gun bore after some cleaning on the lower surfaces. Conservators slowly work back from the gun’s muzzle using hand tools, removing as much concretion as possible.
Gun bored cleaned by hand as far back as possible with normal hand tools (about 22 inches). This makes it easier to set up a coring drill, which can remove all the concretion we can’t reach!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From there it’s a matter of correctly setting up the coring drill, slowly aligning it with the bore, and beginning to drill. We only go in a few inches at a time, before taking the drill back out to remove concretion and make sure the drill isn’t straying off path. The first drill bit we used was a custom-made coring bit. It’s basically a cylinder of pipe with abrasive cutting teeth at the front, made with a diameter of exactly 10.9 inches. The guns have an 11” bore diameter, so a tiny bit of concretion will remain (temporarily)… but using an 11” drill bit in an 11” hole would mean there is absolutely zero room for error, and that any additional abrasive action from loose concretion will start to wear into the gun’s surface. The goal is to get as close as possible, but to leave just enough room to avoid damaging the gun.

Checking the level on the flat rear section of the gun helps let us know if the gun and drill are properly lined up.
Once everything was set up, the forward 10 feet of the bore were gradually cleaned with the coring drill.
It’s important to check periodically and make sure everything is still lined up correctly, and to take loose concretion out of the coring bit. If too much concretion falls into the bit, it starts to wobble around like an unbalanced washing machine! (Also, the drill is turned off, the coolant shut down, and the drill unplugged anytime we work on – or in this case in front of – the drill bit. Safety first!)
The coring bit is about 40 lbs when it’s empty; once it’s filled with water and concretion it gets heavy! We used an engine lift to remove it anytime it needed to be cleaned out.

Once we were near the back of the gun, we needed to change things up a little bit. From the front of the barrel to a depth of 10 feet, the gun bores have a diameter of exactly 11 inches. But the last few inches of the bore form a curved gunpowder chamber, and a cylindrical coring bit can’t be used to clean it. Normally when cleaning a gun with a curved powder chamber, using a drill is impossible; you have to use (very) long chisels. However, if you’ve had the opportunity to research and measure an identical gun… well, that gives some other options!

A smaller coring bit ready to be installed. There is an extra support collar just behind the bit to make sure it stays centered in the now mostly clean gun bore.

We decided to use some more new drilling technology to clean the powder chambers. First, we used a couple of smaller coring drills to remove the bulk of the concretion.

Bullseye! Two smaller cores were used to remove the majority of concretion from the powder chamber; the depth these were drilled to was determined from the original 1851 blueprints for the XI-Inch Dahlgren.
Once those smaller cores had been cut, they could be dragged free and removed from the gun.

We were then able to use a giant spade bit, custom made to the exact shape of the powder chamber (but, like the coring bit, 0.1” smaller) to remove the remaining concretion. Once that was done, all bulk concretion had been removed from the bore – success!

Installing the spade bit used to remove the last concretion from the powder chamber
All clean! With concretion removed from inside the bores, both guns have returned to their tanks to continue removing salts from all the newly-exposed surfaces.

(All images by staff of The Mariners’ Museum and Park)

10 thoughts on “Gun Boring? No! Gun fascinating!”

  1. Absolutely awesome information, and fascinating technical data about all of the effort involved in restoring the U.S.S. Monitor’s weapons system. Thank you for this incredible update, and please do keep it up!! Bo Tomkie, Member since 2019.

    1. Thank you! There will be more updates as we keep working through the conservation, so stay tuned!

  2. Very interesting! Wish I could have seen some of the boring being done. Real experts at work. Congratulations. Jim Taylor

    1. Thank you Jim! If you follow the museum’s Facebook page, there will be a live-stream event 6pm on May 14th where I talk about the process in a bit more detail. It will be mostly pictures, but I’ve got one short video clip from the boring lined up in that.

  3. Just curious,,,,how long did it take to accomplish all this??? Seems like a very painstaking process. Thanks

    1. It is a very painstaking process; the main process of drilling out concretion took about 14-16 hours for each gun. There was also about 18 months of preparation that went into it – cleaning the forward section to let us line up a drill bit, installing new plumbing, research and design for the drill system, and building all the equipment. Like many of the conservation projects that go on at The Mariners’ Museum, this is something we would only ever have one chance to do right, so “painstaking and careful” is very much the name of the game!

    1. …you know, I actually really like the smell from inside of a cannon. Concretion in general has a very distinct iron smell, and especially with guns there’s sometimes a bit of sulfur or the smell of old pitch mixed in. It’s a reminder of what you’re doing and what you’re working on, and while I wouldn’t buy ‘eau de concretion’ cologne anytime soon, it’s genuinely kind of nice. Fresh out of the ocean though… I’ve seen a piece of concretion the size of my arm clear a building with the smell of dead shellfish. So some days definitely smell better than others!

Leave a Reply